Right about what, you ask?
Right about where my Grandma Hankins was born (Villa Mae Lawrence Hankins 1904-1986).
Where was Grandma born?
I was lucky enough to have known her well. Sadly, though, I did not become interested in doing genealogy research until after she died. In her personal notes she stated that her birthplace was Melbourne, Kentucky. So why could I never find any evidence of her family there?
Puzzled, I eventually sent away to the state of Kentucky for a copy of her birth certificate. (That’s how we did it in the olden, pre-internet, days. It wasn’t free, either.) I was so-o-o excited when the envelope finally arrived in the mail…until…well, until I saw that the certificate had been filled out IN HER OWN HANDWRITING!!!!! (Which I recognized from a lifetime of letters and birthday cards.)
My aunt George Ann confirmed and explained that Grandma had needed a copy of her birth certificate so she could file for Social Security benefits. She had never had one, which was not unusual for people born in rural areas at that time. So, she was allowed to fill out her own certificate, with an affidavit from an elderly aunt, stating she’d been born in Melbourne.
Great. So that proves nothing.
When evaluating genealogical data, one must consider the source — how likely are they to know the information? And the proximity in time — sure, Grandma was present at her own birth, but how much is she going to remember about that event?
Grandma also mentioned that her family moved from one town to another in a covered wagon when she was about five years old. I looked at a map – it happened to be a very detailed one, which was pure luck, I realize now – genealogy serendipity — and noticed a town called Milburn located between, and quite near, two other towns where she’d lived, Arlington and Dublin. (There was also a Melber, for that matter, but I think Milburn sounds more like Melbourne than Melber does.)
Despite never finding any more evidence of her family in this location (they eventually settled in Parke County, Indiana), I believed for years that she was born in Milburn, Kentucky, and that she just got it into her head that it sounds, and so must look, like Melbourne. This was all the more logical when you consider that there really is a Kentucky town named Melbourne, clear across the state, and that Milburn is a tiny, unincorporated town that does not appear on most maps.
I eventually found a copy of my own mother’s 1934 birth record on Ancestry.com. The informants were her parents. It states that her mother (my Grandma Hankins) was born in…guess where? Milburn KY!!! So, decades earlier, Grandma did know, and did remember, and reported it correctly. And then forgot. As people do.
1904 Grandma is born.
1911 Kentucky birth registration is enacted statewide.
1934 Grandma states on her child’s birth certificate that she (Grandma) was born in Milburn.
1969 Grandma applies for a delayed birth certificate, stating that she was born in Melbourne.
1986 Grandma dies. (RIP)
1999 I send for a copy of her birth certificate.
2016 My hypothesis is confirmed — case closed!
Have you ever solved a genealogy mystery?
Do you have a mystery that needs solving?
Tell us about it in the comments!
Copyright 2019 by Hazel Thornton, Organized for Life.
I welcome social media links directly to this page!
Please contact me for other types of reprint permission.